← All articles
November 15, 2026
·
Yanik Upasani

Waited Ten Years to Fight for Your Society's Land? The Bombay High Court Says the Door Isn't Shut

Bombay HC says a 10-year delay doesn't kill a society's deemed conveyance claim. What the 5 Nov ruling means for Mumbai flat owners, buyers and NRIs.

Two residential towers with gold patterned facades in Mumbai, with high-rises and the sea in the distance

Imagine living in a building for thirty years, paying every maintenance bill, raising your children there, and then discovering that the land under your home still isn't in your society's name. For a lot of older Mumbai societies, that isn't a thought experiment. It's the reason a redevelopment conversation stalls, a resale buyer's lawyer hesitates, or a bank asks one more question.

That's why a Bombay High Court judgment from 5 November 2026 caught my eye. It doesn't hand out land freely. But it says something important, in plain words: a society that waited too long still hasn't lost its right to ask for title.

What did the Bombay High Court decide?

Justice Sandeep V. Marne delivered the judgment in Sterling Apartment Co-operative Housing Society Ltd v. The Competent Authority and District Deputy Registrar, Co-operative Societies, Mumbai City (3) and Others, Writ Petition No. 8287 of 2026. You can read the full judgment, or the summaries by LawChakra and PropNewz.

The court set aside a 28 March 2016 order that had rejected the society's application for deemed conveyance, and sent the application back to the Competent Authority to decide afresh. As LawChakra quotes paragraph 30 of the judgment: "Thus, mere delay does not defeat the right of a housing society to secure title in the land."

But there's a trade-off. The court said the society "cannot be granted conveyance of the entire plot of land", only a share proportionate to the built-up area of its own building. The parties are to appear before the authority on 19 November 2026, and the matter is to be decided preferably within four months. When one respondent asked for the judgment to be stayed for eight weeks, the court refused.

Why had this society been waiting so long?

The facts, as both reports set them out, are a very Mumbai story:

  • The building, in Kolekalyan, has 38 flats and seven shops. Members bought under agreements governed by the Maharashtra Ownership Flats Act, 1963 (MOFA), and the society was registered on 16 February 1994.
  • Building plans were approved on 29 March 1986, but the building was completed beyond those plans and, the court recorded, is without an occupancy certificate.
  • The developer, M/s National Developers, never conveyed the land and, in the court's words as reported by PropNewz, "has now gone missing from the scene".
  • Eleven other structures stand on the same land, and several people claim title to it.
  • The society's first deemed conveyance application was rejected on 28 March 2016, citing among other things the land's slum status, construction irregularities and rival title claims. The society didn't challenge it.
  • Instead it filed a second application, which was allowed in September 2025 for the entire 2,666.80 sq m plot. In March 2026 the High Court set that order aside because a successive application wasn't maintainable, while leaving the society free to pursue an appropriate civil remedy.

So, by the time of this judgment, the society had been registered for 32 years and the rejection it was challenging was more than ten years old.

Why didn't the ten-year delay sink the case?

The other side argued the petition was "grossly barred by the principles of delay and laches". The court accepted that the society had been negligent in not challenging the 2016 order promptly. LawChakra reports that it still weighed the society's management disputes, the appointment of an administrator, later elections, the need for structural repairs and the pandemic-era exclusion of limitation periods.

The deeper reason is the law itself. MOFA puts a continuing duty on the promoter to convey the land and building. PropNewz quotes the court describing a "continuous cause of action created in favour of the society to secure its due entitlement in the land under Section 11 of MOFA". The judgment also quotes an earlier ruling describing MOFA as "a beneficial legislation" enacted to stop promoters deliberately not conveying land to home buyers.

My reading is that the court is protecting the buyer's basic bargain. When you bought a flat under MOFA, you bought a share in the land too. A missed deadline shouldn't hand that share back to someone else.

Why only a share of the land, and not the whole plot?

Because this society's building doesn't stand alone. Using a 1999 municipal file noting, the court recorded 1,989.31 sq m of built-up area in the society's building and 653.74 sq m in the eleven other structures. The society is entitled to land proportionate to its 1,989.31 sq m (roughly 21,400 sq ft), and must place an architect's certificate before the authority showing its exact entitlement. The remaining land stays with its owners.

I'd treat this as the honest middle path. The society gets a real route to title, but for what its building actually uses, not the whole 2,666.80 sq m it had once been granted.

What's the lesson about filing a second application?

This is the part I'd underline for every committee. The society spent years on a second application that couldn't legally stand, because the first rejection had never been challenged. LawChakra notes the judgment doesn't endorse repeated applications for the same relief; it allowed scrutiny of the original rejection instead. If your society's application was rejected years ago, the first question for your advocate is what happened to that original order.

A missed deadline shouldn't cost a family the land under its own home, but a clean paper trail is still what wins it back.

What this means for you

If you own a flat in an older society

Ask your committee three simple questions: has conveyance or deemed conveyance been done, was any application ever rejected, and was that rejection challenged? Our guide to how deemed conveyance works in Maharashtra explains the process, and if your building is also heading into redevelopment, the 2026 redevelopment rules are worth reading alongside it.

If you're an NRI owner

Conveyance applications need members' agreements and records, and committees often struggle to reach owners abroad. Keep scanned copies of your agreement, share certificate and receipts ready. For homes under our NRI property management, these sit in the TND app so the society can be sent what it needs without a flight home.

If you're buying a resale flat

An unresolved conveyance isn't automatically a deal-breaker, but it should shape the price, the timeline and your loan expectations. Ask for any conveyance order, check the title chain, and ask whether the building has an OC. Our note on buying without an OC and the buyers' tool hub will help.

If you're selling

Buyers' lawyers will ask the same questions, so gather the answers early. Our sellers' guide lists the documents, and a realistic property valuation should factor in the conveyance position.

How we help

We aren't lawyers, and a conveyance matter needs one. What we do is the steady paperwork around it. In one of our published cases in Kandivali East, a buyer's bank found an old agreement on a resale flat that had since been cancelled, and paused the loan; we put together the cancellation papers the bank asked for and kept buyer, seller and bank moving on one timeline. In another, in Parel, a society's records showed money due while the NRI owners were sure they had paid every bill; we asked for the bills and the flat's ledger, found the gap was a one-time share money and entrance fee, and the owners paid it and got a receipt. Clean records are exactly what a conveyance application leans on. You can read more on our Owners' Wall.

Landscaped pool and gardens between high-rise residential towers in Mumbai
A society that holds its land title is in a far stronger position when it plans the future. Have questions about a project's records? Try our RERA helpdesk.

Frequently asked questions

Can a housing society still apply for deemed conveyance after a long delay?

In a judgment dated 5 November 2026, the Bombay High Court held that mere delay does not defeat a society's right to secure title in the land, because MOFA creates a continuing obligation to convey. The court still said each case turns on its facts, and the society was found to have been negligent.

What did the Bombay High Court decide in the Sterling Apartment case?

It set aside a 28 March 2016 order rejecting the society's deemed conveyance application and sent it back to the Competent Authority to work out a proportionate share of land. The parties are to appear on 19 November 2026 and the matter is to be decided preferably within four months. A request for an eight-week stay was refused.

Does a society always get the whole plot under deemed conveyance?

Not always. In this case the court said the society could not be given the entire plot, because other structures stood on the same land. It is entitled to land proportionate to the 1,989.31 sq m of built-up area used for its building.

Our society's deemed conveyance was rejected years ago. Should we just file again?

Be careful. In March 2026 the High Court set aside this society's second application because a successive application was not maintainable after a reasoned rejection. The route that worked was challenging the original order. Take advice from an advocate before you file anything.

Does deemed conveyance give a building an occupancy certificate?

No. The judgment records that this building has no occupancy certificate, and the directions concern conveyance and land division only. They do not regularise the construction or grant an OC.

Related reading

If your society has been stuck on conveyance for years, or you're looking at a flat in a building that never got its land, I'm happy to talk it through with you. Book a video call through our contact page or message us on WhatsApp at +91 88504 51835.

Warmly,
Yanik

This is general information based on a published judgment, not legal advice. The remanded proceedings may change the outcome, so please speak to a qualified advocate about your own society.

Own a flat in Mumbai while living abroad?

TND Listings manages, sells and helps you buy property across Mumbai, Navi Mumbai and Thane, with one point of contact.