Transit Rent During Redevelopment: Is It Taxable? What the Bombay High Court Said
The Bombay High Court held that transit rent paid by developers is a capital receipt, not taxable income, and not subject to TDS. What society members should know.
When a Mumbai society goes for redevelopment, members move out and the developer pays them a monthly transit rent (also called displacement compensation or hardship allowance) until the new flat is ready. Members often ask whether this money is taxed.
What the Bombay High Court held
In Sarfaraz S. Furniturewalla v. Afshan Sharfali Ashok Kumar & Ors. (2024), the Bombay High Court held that transit rent paid to members during redevelopment is a capital receipt, not revenue, and so not chargeable to tax. It also held that the developer need not deduct TDS under section 194-I on it.
The reasoning
- Ordinary rent is a periodic payment for using a property, which is income.
- Transit rent compensates for the hardship of being displaced and temporarily relocated.
- Since it isn't taxable, the TDS question doesn't arise.
Commentary also cites an earlier Tribunal ruling, Devshi Lakhamshi Dedhia v. ACIT, treating hardship and rehabilitation allowances as capital in nature.
Transit rent compensates you for being displaced. The court treated it as a hardship payment, not rent for using a property.
What this means for members
- Keep the redevelopment agreement that sets out transit rent as compensation for displacement.
- If a developer deducts TDS on transit rent, ask them to stop, citing the ruling, and claim credit for anything already deducted in your return.
- Don't confuse it with other income. If you sub-let your transit flat or earn interest on corpus money, that income is taxed normally.
- Disclosure. Ask your CA how to report it in your return.
A caution
The ruling was given under the Income-tax Act, 1961. The Income-tax Act, 2025 applies from tax year 2026-27. The principle that capital receipts aren't income should carry over, but ask your CA, especially if the Department takes a different view in your case.
Related reading
Is your society going for redevelopment? We can find tenants or a transit flat for you. Book a video call.
Sources
- Mondaq: Transit rent (Bombay HC and ITAT rulings)
- PropertyPistol: Bombay HC declares transit rent non-taxable
- Moneylife: Transit rent not taxable, not subject to TDS
General information, not tax advice. Speak to a chartered accountant.
Own a flat in Mumbai while living abroad?
TND Listings manages, sells and helps you buy property across Mumbai, Navi Mumbai and Thane, with one point of contact.
TND Listings is a professional real estate brokerage company serving buyers, sellers, NRIs and Private Institutes. At TND Listings, you are number one. We believe in integrity, commitment to excellence, a professional attitude, and personalised care.
→
Off Veera Desai Road, Andheri West,
Mumbai, Maharashtra 400053 +91 88504 51835
Prabhadevi, Mumbai,
Maharashtra 400025 +91 8850451835
Shakespeare Sarani, Kolkata,
West Bengal 700017 +91 88504 51835
Thakur Village, Kandivali East,
Mumbai, Maharashtra 400101 +91 88504 51835
CIN: U68100MH2025PTC448661
© 2020 – 2026 TND Listings Private Limited, operating under the brands TND Listings and The New Door · CIN U68100MH2025PTC448661 · MahaRERA Agent Reg. No. A51800024511